Egg Nog Ice Cream Recipes: Poke Cake, Shake, Pie, and Cheesecake
Four easy egg nog ice cream recipes built from one carton and a few pantry staples. No ice cream maker needed.
Egg nog ice cream recipes get a lot simpler when you start with a store-bought carton. It shows up every holiday season, and Braum’s carries a seasonal one too. Below are four ways to use it: a poke cake, a peppermint shake, a pumpkin pie, and a cheesecake. Each takes about 20 minutes of hands-on work. Short on time? Start with the shake. Feeding a crowd? The poke cake serves 12.
1. Egg Nog Ice Cream Poke Cake
This poke cake is a yellow cake soaked in egg nog, then topped with a layer of egg nog ice cream and whipped topping. It’s cold, sweet, and tastes like a holiday party in a pan. You use a boxed mix, so most of the work is waiting around while the freezer does its thing. It’s also the easiest one to make for a crowd, since a single pan cuts into 12 squares.
Serves 12. Prep 25 minutes, bake 30 minutes, freeze 3 hours.
Ingredients
- 1 box yellow cake mix (about 15 oz), plus the eggs, oil, and water listed on the box
- 1 cup cold egg nog, any store-bought kind
- 1 quart egg nog ice cream, set out for 10 minutes so it’s soft enough to spread
- 8 oz whipped topping, thawed in the fridge
- Ground nutmeg, for dusting
- Cooking spray, for the pan

Step By Steps Guide
Step#1:
Heat the oven and prep the pan. Set the oven to the temperature on the cake mix box, usually 350°F. Spray a 9×13 pan well so the squares lift out clean late

Step#2:
Mix and bake the cake. Make the batter exactly the way the box says, then pour it into the pan. Bake until a toothpick in the center comes out clean, usually 28 to 33 minutes.

Step#3:
Let it cool 10 minutes. You want it warm, not hot. A warm cake soaks up egg nog better than a cold one, and a hot cake can turn gummy.
Step#4:
Poke the holes. Push the handle of a wooden spoon almost to the bottom of the cake, about every inch. Wiggle it a little so the holes stay open. You’ll end up with around 100 holes, and that’s what you want.

Step#5:
Pour in the egg nog. Pour the cup of egg nog slowly over the cake in a zigzag so it runs into the holes instead of pooling on top. If puddles form, wait 30 seconds and keep going. Refrigerate 30 minutes so the cake drinks it all in.

Step#6:
Add the ice cream. Dollop the softened ice cream over the cake and spread it to the edges with an offset spatula or the back of a spoon. Freeze 1 hour, until the layer is firm.

Step#7:
Top it off. Spread the whipped topping over the ice cream and dust the whole thing with nutmeg. Cover loosely with foil and freeze 2 more hours.

Step#8:
Slice and serve. Run a knife under hot water, wipe it dry, and cut 12 squares. Heat the knife again every couple of cuts so the edges stay neat.


Tips
If the ice cream gets runny while you spread it, slide the pan back into the freezer for 15 minutes and try again.
Spice cake mix or white cake mix both work if you don’t have yellow.
Want a less sweet topping? Whip 1 cup cold heavy cream with 2 tablespoons powdered sugar and use that instead of whipped topping.
Cover the pan tightly and the cake keeps in the freezer for up to 2 weeks. Let it sit on the counter 5 minutes before cutting.
Quick answers
Can I use homemade egg nog?
Yes, as long as it’s fully chilled. If yours is thin, pour a little less so the cake doesn’t get soggy.
Can I make it ahead?
Yes. It actually slices cleaner after a full night in the freezer.
What goes on top besides nutmeg?
Crushed candy canes or chocolate shavings both look great, and neither needs extra work.

